Loading...

PAUSED
previous play/pause next

Objectives

This paper presents three case studies of literacy teachers in Indonesia who come from different backgrounds of socioeconomic and cultural identities. The presentation aims to make sense of the focal teachers’ agency in teaching intercultural awareness. Using an ecological perspective of teacher agency (Biesta &Tedder, 2007), this research seeks to understand what kinds of cultural, structural, and material factors support their agentic selves as teachers, which then motivate their decision to teach intercultural awareness. Our definition of intercultural awareness is one’s understanding of their and other cultures in terms of “the similarities and differences between them” (IGI-Global website). What we mean by intercultural awareness in this study is the extent to which the focal teachers consider teaching about cultural values that are different from the values commonly embraced in their school settings.

OPEN

Theoretical framework

This research used an ecological perspective of teacher agency (Biesta &Tedder, 2007) as the theoretical framework. We subscribe to the idea that teacher agency is “achieved in a transaction with a particular context-for-action, within a particular ' ‘ecology’” (p. 137). Biesta and colleagues argue that teachers rely on cultural, structural, and material factors when making a practical teaching decision. The lack of some of them influences their ability to exercise teacher agency. A cultural factor refers to one’s narratives whose manifestation can be seen through the values and beliefs that the person subscribes to, e.g., a life history that motivates one’s tendency to value diversity. A structural factor refers to the social structures constituting relationships, power, and trust. One example is a teacher’s ability to maintain relationships that grow trust with colleagues and school leaders. A material factor points to the availability of resources for the teacher (Biesta, Priestley, & Robinson, 2015), e.g., having means at their disposal. Together, the cultural, structural, and material factors arguably make it possible for teachers to consider alternatives that motivate their agency.

OPEN

Methods

This research employs a qualitative case study (Yin, 2018) because the purpose was to seek to understand teacher agency of the focal teachers, as they teach intercultural awareness in class, and the best approach to accomplish it is through a case study research methodology (Biesta & Tedder, 2007; Cloonan, Hutchison, & Paatsch, 2019). The focal teachers were Ms. Nadya, Mr. Irza, and Mr. Yadi (all pseudonyms). They were among the first Indonesian teachers to receive literacy master teacher’s training sponsored by the Indonesian government. The program focused on children’s book use in reading and writing workshops. It was one of the concrete efforts from the government in responding to Indonesia’s long struggle with the PISA report's low literacy index (OECD, 2018).

Ms. Nadya was a female veteran teacher serving in a private primary Islamic school in Samarinda city in East Kalimantan. Mr. Irza was a male veteran teacher at a public primary school on the outskirts of Surabaya city in East Java. Mr. Yadi was a junior male teacher serving in a public primary school in a remote Malinau regency in North Kalimantan. (See table 1 for teacher participants’ characteristics by gender, age, qualification, and years of experience). 

The data came from two sources. First, in a focus group discussion, the focal teachers talked about their initial conception of intercultural awareness and the relevant teaching experiences. The second data came from an individual interview following up on the questions that needed further elaborations, especially regarding the teachers’ life histories that needed clarifications. The focus group discussion and interview became the primary data sources of the study.

OPEN

Data sources

Ms. Nadya

Cultural. Nadya shows a solid commitment to promoting gender equality. She believes girls can do activities associated with boys and brings such discussions to her class. Nadya’s sense of gender equality came from her parents’ upbringing, who treated males and females in equal treatment. Nadya was once married and confessed that the divorce was due to the conflicting value about playing an equal role in the marriage. Nadya promotes gender equality in her classroom. Nadya saw herself as an agent in an Islamic school that was sometimes interpreted as restricted to women. Nadya has a regular movie watching with students about a story that promotes equal gender participation, e.g., girls' soccer. Nadya was eager to learn more about teaching intercultural awareness in her classroom.

Structural. Nadya has been a teacher in the school for 18 years and is considered an exemplary teacher. Nadya believes that the biggest power in the classroom comes from teachers. She offered a shadow curriculum in class that promoted gender equality and learned to navigate a restricted Islamic interpretation of teachings in the school.

Material. As a private school, Nadya's school can afford to incorporate movie-watching activities suggesting that her school has physical resources.
Mr. Irza
Cultural. Irza grew up with parents who were economically struggling. As a child, Irza had to support himself and finish his education. Irza long aspired to become a teacher helping children to meet their potential and life opportunities. Irza considered himself different regarding owning life values and freedom. He used his brief marriage as an example that he refused to conform to the social pressure that, as a teacher, he should live a ‘normal’ marriage. Many of Irza’s point of view is considered strange by his family. He tends to be critical of religious conservatism (he is a Muslim). He once confronted a religious teacher whose interpretations of an Islamic scripture went against logic and humanistic value. He credited much of his intercultural awareness experience to his participation in a global citizen program sponsored by the Indonesian government. For three months, he visited Asian countries meeting teachers and students. The experience opened his eyes to diversity and exposed him to many different values. Irza’s network from the global citizen program is wide, exposing him to issues such as LGBTQ. He considered himself an ally. Irza teaches intercultural awareness values in his class. He once defended a student bullied for looking feminine and used that case to teach his students in class about respecting differences and encouraging them to speak up when they see a bully. Irza believes every individual has worth and value to contribute, so one must take the opportunity in life. For Irza, students need to hear that message from a teacher because Irza missed that life affirmation growing up.

Structural. Irza is a veteran teacher in his school and is considered an exemplary teacher with many achievements, which gained him respect from his colleagues and school leaders. Irza is known to be a very dedicated teacher and close to students. Irza confessed to being a private person, but he maintained a good relationship with his school principal and confided in her about his personal life (about ending his marriage). The principal was able to keep the matter confidential. These altogether made Irza feel safe and free to teach based on his values.
Material. Despite the school's limited resources, Irza secured a place for reading and writing workshops. It seems the respect for being a qualified and dedicated teacher allows Irza to find help around the school that can support his teaching goal. Irza used his global citizen networks as a pool of resources to invite guest speakers to his classroom. People of different cultures and faiths talk to his students, giving the students a chance to research and inquire about the culture of the guest speakers.
Mr. Yadi
Cultural. Yadi is a newcomer who called Malinau home only three years ago. He came as a literacy activist and later was selected to become the region’s public teacher. Malinau’s population is predominantly a Dayak ethnic group that follows Christianity, and Yadi’s background belongs to none of them, which seemed to influence his way of thinking. Yadi tends to be critical of the natives’ way of living. They highly value a farming tradition that they often sacrifice their commitment as government employees; they often leave their office midday to tend their lands. At times Yadi seems quite puzzled by the prevalent culture of farming among locals, who like to bring their school children to farms after school instead of doing something educational. But at the same time, Dedy profoundly cares about the people in Malinau. Yadi is motivated to see them be open to the world and be more balanced in preserving land-tending culture with the current occupation and profession.

Structural. Malinau is populated by the Dayak ethnic group, with several subethnic groups competing to influence local politics. That dynamic also enters Yadi's classroom, where the students' compositions reflect the region's population. Being an outsider, Yadi feels the natives view him as not politically threatening. Yadi earned the respect of school leaders and parents for being regularly invited to programs sponsored by the Indonesian government, which gave him a sense of freedom to teach what he valued by exposing his students to differences. As he said, his being an outsider (a minority) motivated Yadi to do something different in class. For instance, he promotes group classroom activities that enable students of mixed backgrounds to interact.

Material. Yadi feels motivated to teach intercultural awareness but struggles with the scarcity of resources. Yadi leveraged his network as a community literacy activist to compensate for the lack of resources. His literacy community club is thriving in the region. As a literacy activist, Mr. Yadi’s network can afford him to access support from nongovernmental literacy programs.

(See table 2 for a visual of the cultural, structural, and material factors of the teacher participants).

OPEN

Results

The cultural factor understood as the teacher's life histories and narratives plays a significant role in the focal teachers when making decisions about teaching and is found in all teacher participants. For instance, the focal teachers are quite alike regarding how 

they value intercultural awareness, teaching their students cultural values not commonly subscribed to in their school settings. Similarly, the cultural factor for being exemplary teachers earned the respect of school leaders in their respective schools, giving them a sense of recognition for being good teachers. They appear to gain power and trust regarding how they conduct teaching in their classrooms. They have the freedom to promote what they value, teaching intercultural awareness.

Yet, they are not alike regarding the material factor. For example, Ms. Nadya, a private school teacher, has more leverage to support that value in the form of physical resources such as equipment for movie watching. While receiving less leverage, Mr. Irza had the freedom to promote his intercultural awareness value by accessing his network of multicultural guest speakers. Mr. Yadi was somewhat different because he complimented his lack of resources by activating a literacy community he helped establish prior teaching in a public school in that region.

OPEN

OPEN

Scholarly significance of the study

Agency is not a state of individual quality to achieve. Instead, seen from an ecological perspective, teacher agency is an achievement manifested through interaction with multiple factors from the cultural, structural, and material available for teachers to consider (Biesta et al., 2015). For the focal teachers, a cultural factor plays a significant role in moving forward their decision to teach intercultural awareness in their classroom. Through the lens of the structural factor, one can see that the teachers maintain their status and relationship in school by displaying their achievements as exemplary teachers. In terms of the material factors, however, they are pretty different. In Ms. Nadya's case, she teaches in a private Islamic school with some material support. Mr.

Irza’s network of multicultural figures compensated for his modest support from the public funds. Meanwhile, Mr. Yadi complemented his lack of material support by extending his literacy community activity in parallel with classroom teaching.

Overall, the teacher’s cultural and structural factors appear to be the dominant motivation for teachers to exercise their agency. The life narratives and being good at their profession seem to motivate them to exercise the freedom to teach intercultural awareness, even being resourceful by using their network when the material support in their schools is lacking.

 

 

OPEN
Edit
Delete

Notice!

Your iPoster has now been unpublished and will not be displayed on the iPoster Gallery.

You need to publish it again if you want to be displayed.

You are not registered!

Your have to register before you can publish your iPoster.

If you have recently registered it may take up to 10 min before your registration status is updated in our system.

Sorry but time is up!

Because of maintenance we have just saved your content and will within a few minutes logout all users and restart our server. We will be back in a moment.

Sorry for the inconvenience!

Because of maintenance we will within a few minutes restart our server. We will be back in a moment.

Sorry for the inconvenience!

Thank you for contributing to the success of the AERA 2023 Annual Meeting.

Editing has been turned off but you can still access a number of communication and networking functions on your i-Presentation:

• Add a Narration
• Add a Video Presentation
• Set up a Text or Video Chat in When I'm Available
• Print your i-Presentation to a PDF document
• Share your i-Presentation
• View and respond to Comments in My Settings
• Change your Display setting in My Settings
• View Your Statistics in My Settings

As of August 30, 2023 the i-Presentation Gallery will be Open Access and you are welcome to freely share the link with your peers so that they can explore the research.

If you have any questions, please contact [email protected]

00:00

Contact Author

Get iPoster

CONTACT AUTHOR


GET IPOSTER

Please enter your email address in the field below and a link to this iPoster will be sent to you.
Use the text box to add a personal note to yourself.

NOTE: Your email address will be shared with the author, but your personal notes will not.


0